Exercise as a Stress Management Modality
When asked how they cope with stress a large percentage of people indicate
that they use exercise as their primary coping resource. How can
an activity that is physiologically almost identical to the physiological
response of psychological stress be helpful as a coping technique?
What follows is a working paper on how physical activity can function as
a therapeutic modality. Also included are recommendations on the
use of physical activity to promote emotional health. If you have
other ideas, or are aware of additional research not cited on this page,
please communicate with the author.
Click here for a list of scientific references on Exercise
and Emotional Health.
-
Detoxification of Stress Related Compounds: During the stress response
somewhere in the neighborhood of 1500 biochemical reactions occur in the
body. Neurotransmitters are activated, hormones are released, and
nutrients are metabolized. Some body systems (e.g., the cardiovascular
system) accelerate their functions and others (e.g., the gastrointestinal
system) slow down their operations in response to stress. This is
commonly referred to as the fight of flight response. The body is
being prepared to expend physical energy which in prehistoric times was
necessary for survival. In modern times most human stress is psycho-social
in nature, so the need to respond physically in most cases is unnecessary.
Unfortunately the byproducts of the stress response continue to circulate
in the body and have the potential to create physical illness (e.g., cortisol
secretion's impact on the immune system). Regular exercise is useful
in removing the byproducts of the stress response by providing the opportunity
to simulate the fighting or running dictated by the fight or flight phenomenon.
As such, regular exercise allows the body to return to homeostasis faster
and reduce the physical impact of psycho-social stress.
-
Physical Activity as an Outlet for Anger and Hostility: Recent research
has documented the important role that expression or repression of anger
and hostility plays in disease progression. For many, physical activity
is a healthy catharsis for this most caustic of emotions. Used properly
(see recommendations below) exercise provides a socially acceptable means
of physically releasing negative energy. Whether one gets in a racquetball
court and bangs away at at a ball, or beats up on their pillow, the physical
release of energy appears to dissipate feelings of anger in a healthy way.
-
Moving Meditation: Certain forms of exercise (jogging, cross country
skiing, swimming, hiking, bicycling) require a fairly consistent repetitive
motion that can alter one's state of consciousness. Described by
some as moving meditation, the physiological effects of regular participation
in these activities is very similar to what happens when one practices
meditation. Breathing and movement, act as a mantra and may in part
be responsible for the feelings of calmness and tranquility claimed by
some in response to exercise.
-
Enhanced Feelings of Self Esteem and Self Efficacy: Appropriately
high levels of self esteem and self efficacy have been correlated with
increased ability to cope with high stress levels. Exercise cultivates
self esteem and self efficacy in a number of ways including; a. when ever
an individual knowingly participates in a health enhancing activity it
is common to experience increased feelings of self worth as one realizes
they are doing something which will ultimately benefit them, b. participation
in physical activities that have known social value attached to them, promotes
social acceptance and status, c. an added benefit of regular physical activity
is that it has the potential to alter one's body image in a socially desirable
manner thus increasing self image and improving self esteem, d. frequent
physical activity also promotes consistent physical challenges which when
conquered, foster feelings of self efficacy.
-
Periodic Solitude and Introspection: For some, exercise is a solitary
escape from the daily toils and pressures of a stressful society.
The escape can be a bicycle ride in the country, the cocoon of a lap pool,
an early morning run, or any other form of physical exertion that provides
a mini vacation and allows one to recharge their energy levels to deal
with conflicts when they return. Others use this time to self reflect on
issues of importance, or to stimulate creative problem solving.
-
Opportunities for Social Support: The buffering effects of social
support are well documented. Recreational activities (softball, golf, a
fun run, a pick up game of basketball) encourage a sense of fun and play
with other individuals that have similar interests and can provide a number
opportunities to discuss life situations. The sharing that ensues,
ensures one that they are not alone and that help is available for the
asking.
-
The Power of Human Touch: A significant volume of research is accumulating
on the positive physical properties of human touch. Some of the research
has demonstrated a reduction in stress related hormones accompanying positive
expressions of human touch. Recreational and sporting endeavors raise
occasions and provide excuses to touch others in a positive way.
As an example, in a culture that breeds homophobia, men are told that it
is socially acceptable to hug other men and pat them on the buttocks during
sporting events. This behavior is normally considered taboo and many
men would otherwise have few chances to express emotions in such a physical
manner.
-
Reduction of Muscular Tension: During stress muscles contract (Bracing)
and loose their normal resting muscle tone. Bouts of physical activity
allow muscles to work, thereby releasing stored energy and allowing muscle
groups to return to their normal resting potential. This action also
reduces further stress that is precipitated by pain and discomfort associated
with muscular tension (e.g., tension headaches, arthritic joint pain, backache,
temporomandibular joint dysfunction). Stretching and yoga are also
effective in reducing muscular tension.
-
Endorphin Theories: Catecholamines including ß endorphins
have been shown to increase during physical activity of twenty minutes
or more. Chemically similar to opiate compounds this morphine like
substance has been shown to provide an analgesic (pain relieving) effect
and promote a sense of euphoria. First suggested as the mechanism
of the so called second wind or runner's high, the presence and effect
of these chemical compounds in the brain is now controversial (see: Stoll,
O. (1997) Endogenous opiates, Runner's High and Exercise Addiction - The
rise and decline of a myth (Endogene Opiate, Runner's High und Laufsucht
- Austieg und Niedergang eines Mythos). Leipziger Sportwissenschaftliche
Beitraege.). The physical and emotional symptoms of withdrawal associated
with the rapid decrease of physical activity (as occurs with athletic injuries)
of physically fit individuals has also been attributed to this hormone.
Most of the controversy in this area has do to with our inability to measure
chemical changes that occur on the other side of the blood brain barrier.
Regardless of the neuro chemical reaction or other mechanisms that initiate
changes in emotional status, this phenomenon does seem to exist.
The positive mood states associated with frequent exercise are so significant
that some have suggested that this is a more effective treatment for clinical
depression than either psychotherapy, or the use anti depression drugs.
-
Increased Somatic Awareness: One of the byproducts of relaxation
training is that practitioners develop an increased sense of somatic awareness.
This means that they become more in tuned with their body. They are
able to detect subtle changes in their physiology that they were previously
unaware of (e.g., breathing depth and respiration, muscular tension, heart
rate). This new awareness allows individuals to be able to circumvent
the physiological process of stress before it can cause problems.
Regular physical activity will enhance the same awareness. As a result
it is much easier to teach relaxation training to physically fit individuals.
Conversely, those who are the most out of touch with their bodies, have
the most difficulty in learning to alter their physiology in a health enhancing
way.
-
Decreased Boredom and the Stress of High Risk Activities:
Too little stress in one's life can be just as upsetting as too much stress.
It is natural for humans to seek out stimulation and excitement.
For some the opportunity for physical challenges is the most interesting
part of life. This urge can be expressed through activities such
as running as fast as one can, swimming as far as one can, or hitting a
golf ball as straight and hard as possible. On the far end of the
continuum are people who voluntarily involve themselves in high risk physical
activities such as extreme skiing, hang gliding, scuba diving, and jumping
out of perfectly good airplanes. By constantly testing themselves
individuals learn how to take on higher and higher loads of stress.
The learning that ensues transfers over to stress that is experienced in
daily life. For example, it would be difficult to imagine someone
spending all day solo rock climbing without the use of ropes for safety,
driving back into a city and getting upset over being caught in traffic.
-
Training for Competition: Being related to physical activity, many
advocates of competitive sports contend that participants learn a great
deal about life and what is necessary for success through their participation.
Knowing what it takes to win, how to accept loss, how to set goals, how
to deal with high levels of stress, and how to get along with others are
all mentioned as lessons learned through involvement in sports.
-
Improvement in Sleep and Rest: A symptom of stress overload
for some is the inability to sleep or get adequate rest. A fatigued
individual is less able to perform at a high level. Exercise has
been shown to be very effective in helping some individuals fall asleep
easily and sleep more soundly. The assumption is that one is not
over doing physical training and becoming exhausted from the activity.
-
Fitter to Fight Stress and Disease: One who is physically
fit has organ systems that are functioning at an optimal level. If
this individual should become ill, or injured, or even pregnant, they will
demonstrate more stamina and greater resiliency to fight the discomfort
. It is also likely that fit individuals will recover more quickly.
-
Others? I am always looking for other explanations of how physical
activity may e helpful in dealing with stress. E-mail me if you have
suggestions.
General Recommendations
The therapeutic benefits of regular physical activity is without rival.
Study after study has shown that it increases longevity while decreasing
morbidity and mortality from a host of diseases. Someone once said
that if exercise was a pill, it would be the most powerful medication known
to humans. The only problem is that it is difficult to get modern
men and women to take that pill every day. Inactivity should be considered
a dis-ease state.
Adults are often told that they should consult a physician before beginning
an exercise program. Based upon scientific evidence, it may be more
appropriate to consult a physician before sitting down in a lounge chair
in front of a TV with a remote control.
Stressed out individuals often complain that they do not have time to
exercise. This is unusual when one considers that a high percentage
of CEOs of fortune five hundred companies indicate that they exercise on
a regular basis. Even the president of our country seems to find
time in his busy schedule to jog and play golf. Don't these folks
have anything better to do with their time? It is more likely that
they have learned to be competitive and at their best only when they make
the time to sweat and get their hearts pumping.
What types of physical activities are recommended for stress and emotional
health management?
-
The form of exercise chosen should be enjoyable. Individuals
will be more likely to continue activities that they perceive as fun compared
to those that are viewed as pure drudgery. If you don't like running,
then don't run. Why do that to yourself? Involvement in negative
activities will only work to increase one's depression and stress level.
-
Activities should be non-competitive and ego void. Although
competition was highlighted above as a positive function, for some wining
becomes the most important part of competition. The downside of competition
for overly competitive people is that they sometimes lose. This works
to decrease esteem and increase depression. One can either compete
against opponents that they will always beat (boring), or choose not to
enter competitive activities. For some this is more difficult than
it may seem. If the classic Type A person takes up running to reduce
stress, they will be likely to purchase a running watch and each time they
run they will try and run faster than the last time they ran. That
does not do much to reduce stress.
-
Choose activities that promote personal satisfaction. Although
some say they play golf to relax, I personally can find few activities
that are as stressful. Trying to hit a tiny ball hundreds of yards
into a tiny hole is not relaxing. Someone once described golf as
a good way to screw-up a nice walk. Perhaps because my skill level
is so low, when invited to play with friends I do not enjoy looking like
a buffoon as I spend most of my time looking for lost balls. On the
other hand if I am playing with my wife who is also somewhat inept, we
can just enjoying being outdoors together and not worry about the score.
In general, try to find activities that promote positive feelings regarding
your performance.
-
Aerobic Vs. anaerobic activities Activities performed at a
long slow steady interval seem to have a calming effect on people.
One study indicated that male long distance runners experience a decrease
in testosterone levels. Associated with hyper aggressiveness, this
hormonal change may very useful to some. On the other hand, the opposite
seems to occur with high intensity training. Spend time in any busy
weight room and you can almost feel the testosterone being pumped up.
The high one gets from lifting weights is not the same as the tranquility
experienced by those who condition aerobically. Weight lifters feel
powerful and confident following workouts. From a physical health
perspective aerobic activities are generally considered superior in reducing
the risks associated with most diseases (especially heart disease).
Weight training appears to be be more effective in reducing the risk of
osteoporosis. From a mental health perspective I would recommend
cross training in both aerobic and anaerobic exercise to increase variety
in workouts while encouraging feelings of both powerfulness and tranquility.
-
How much exercise? The frequency and duration of exercise
is determined by ones goals. To get in shape quicker it is recommended
that one exercise frequently as opposed to fewer times and longer durations.
Weekend athletes don't cut it. In most cases fitness will be
lost at less than three sessions a week. Ideally one should attempt
to do something physical each day to prepare for the stressors ahead or
to decrease the residual effects of stress during the day.
-
Sexual activity as exercise Don't forget to include sexual
activity as part of your physical activity. Orgasm is a great release
of muscular and emotional tension. Like other forms of physical activity,
make sure it is fun and not stressful. It is also good if you can
include someone you like in your activity.
Negative consequences and contraindications
-
Compulsive Training Like any activity exercise can have its downside.
Overuse of any coping strategy can create additional problems. For
some, physical activity can be escape from taking responsibility for ones
actions. By indulging themselves in their activity, they avoid troubling
life situations which are difficult to resolve. Similarly, although
most can benefit from increased levels of self esteem, this is different
from the unhealthy narcissistic tendencies others derive from physical
training.
-
Aggressive Tendencies Although physical activity can be a
useful catharsis for aggression, aggressive sport activities can also act
to condition one to become more aggressive. If one learns to be successful
by acting overly aggressive, it is not a far stretch to see how some may
use this aggression to get what they want in other areas of life.
Not a very positive consequence of physical activity and certainly one
that can increase stress and negative emotional reactions.
-
Addiction Those who exercise on a daily basis often describe
being addicted to their activity. Although considered to be a positive
addiction to some, the withdrawal effects of not being able to exercise
can create problems. Whether caused by changes in catecholamines
levels (not getting their daily fix of endorphins) or some other mechanism,
individuals should be aware of possible increases in hostility, anxiety,
irritability and depression associated with not working out.
http://www.OptimalHealthConcepts.com/ExerciseStress.html
Return to the Stress
Management and Emotional Wellness Links Page
Learn how Optimal
Health Concepts can help
About
the author
Return to Optimal Health
Concepts Home Page